As the students began filing in from recess, Miss Sophia began writing a word onto the board.
P-E-N-M-A-N-S-H-I-P
"Penmanship, this is a very important skill that you all need to...Uh, yes Cales."
Miss California Aphron had shot her hand up very quickly. She was the only kindergartener who refused to play with the other kids on account of their childishness.
"Yes. Miss Sophia, I find the word you've chosen highly offensive. Penmanship excludes women, the correct term would be handwriting."
Without blinking, Miss Sophia responded, "Your are absolutely right Cales, and right after class I will tell you why I did not use it."
***
After class, California went straight up to Miss Sophia, and stared directly at her until all the other children had exited the classroom.
Miss Sophia set down the papers she had been grading and said, "Now, you were concerned that by using the word 'penmanship' I might be offending people. And you are absolutely right in that we should be careful how we speak, because it might offend people. One wrong word can easily upset someone in an unnecessary and avoidable way.
"But you see, I did not use your suggested term 'handwriting' because I did not also want to offend those without hands. It would be all too painful for them to be constantly reminded that they cannot write well, if at all. And this would be far more painful, I find, to be constantly reminded of a handicap, than a reminder of being a female."
"Yes, but Miss Sophia," California said, "we have no students here with handicaps. You must also keep in mind who your audience is."
Miss Sophia laughed, "Of course you're right. But children are very prone to repeat the things they hear. And if they went about. repeating such terminology around others, they are far more likely to bring about a painful reminder to some unsuspecting victim.
"Now it is possible for me to have used simply the term 'writing,' as that would have avoided offending many people, but then that could cause much confusion. In a world that is constantly advancing technologically, one could easily mistake 'writing' to mean, 'texting,' or 'typing up an e-mail.' So the term 'writing' didn't exactly fit either."
California looked down at her tennis shoes and sighed. "Ma'am, I can see what you are saying, and one cannot go very far before taking these offenses into account can become awkward. But you have become very sloppy in the way you speak. Perhaps becoming upset over this specific word was the wrong time for me to try and prove my point, but there have been many other times I planned to say something and refrained from speaking, much to my later regret. For instance, the other day you used the word 'police man,' when you could have instead said 'Police officer.' Words like 'manage', 'mania', and 'manners', all of these words mean positive things, and exclude women as a part of it. You really must learn to take these things into account, being a worker of the state in a public school."
"Ahh yes, but you are forgetting words like 'maniac', 'demanding', and 'mandibles'. The first refers to a person of unsavory nature, the second referring to a character trait that no one wishes to be identified with, and the last ones are an unsightly growth on some animals. We are more likely the ones subjecting men to these harms, and yet we do not see them complaining. And do not forget as well, that in changing 'man' to 'woman' you still must incorporate the word 'man.'"
"But we must see fit that women, er, females get the respect they deserve. It is not so much what the word means that is the problem, it is the fact that females are excluded from it. Whether or not people will see it, women are discriminated against!" California said, raising her voice. "Have we ever had a woman president? Of course not! Despite the fact that they've given us the right to vote, and dress according to our wills, they still discriminate according to sexes!"
"Is that really the reason women are not being voted into presidency? African Americans were once considered lower than women, and yet we see today--"
"An African American man."
"--Does the fact that no woman has become president necessarily follow that it is because they are discriminated against? I'm sure with plenty of people like you in the world that is not the problem. Perhaps we have either 1) had unequipped women, excuse me, females," Miss Sophia said with a wink, "running for office, 2) they are, in comparison to other male candidates, a worse choice, 3) they are not Republican or Democratic, and are not being voted on by the majority of our country because the parties containing the most voters is not the one they identify with.
"And are we to find a solution to this problem, if it is indeed a problem, through changing our many vocabulary words containing the term 'man'? I am certain when someone's house is burning down, no one's concern is whether or not they call firemen by their proper, unsexist names. Their only concern is likely to put the fire out.
"You see, people will always be offended, there are people in the world whose purposes are to search for why the world hates them. These people are called 'victims' (they should be happy to see that this word does not exclude any gender.)"
California was upset, very clearly. She was obviously being picked on for her age, she was unequipped to debate someone more than several times her age. People pick on her, and it's because they don't like conflict. They want to remain shut up in their senseless little worlds without reason.
As she silently left, Miss Sophia's husband, Cosmo, entered the room. He noticed California and remained standing, holding the door open with a smile. California inwardly groaned, Typical, she thought, treating me as if I am unequipped to open a door. She stormed out, shaking her head, and with one last glance back, she saw Miss Sophia laughing as Cosmo shrugged his shoulders.

P-E-N-M-A-N-S-H-I-P
"Penmanship, this is a very important skill that you all need to...Uh, yes Cales."
Miss California Aphron had shot her hand up very quickly. She was the only kindergartener who refused to play with the other kids on account of their childishness.
"Yes. Miss Sophia, I find the word you've chosen highly offensive. Penmanship excludes women, the correct term would be handwriting."
Without blinking, Miss Sophia responded, "Your are absolutely right Cales, and right after class I will tell you why I did not use it."
***
After class, California went straight up to Miss Sophia, and stared directly at her until all the other children had exited the classroom.
Miss Sophia set down the papers she had been grading and said, "Now, you were concerned that by using the word 'penmanship' I might be offending people. And you are absolutely right in that we should be careful how we speak, because it might offend people. One wrong word can easily upset someone in an unnecessary and avoidable way.
"But you see, I did not use your suggested term 'handwriting' because I did not also want to offend those without hands. It would be all too painful for them to be constantly reminded that they cannot write well, if at all. And this would be far more painful, I find, to be constantly reminded of a handicap, than a reminder of being a female."
"Yes, but Miss Sophia," California said, "we have no students here with handicaps. You must also keep in mind who your audience is."
Miss Sophia laughed, "Of course you're right. But children are very prone to repeat the things they hear. And if they went about. repeating such terminology around others, they are far more likely to bring about a painful reminder to some unsuspecting victim.
"Now it is possible for me to have used simply the term 'writing,' as that would have avoided offending many people, but then that could cause much confusion. In a world that is constantly advancing technologically, one could easily mistake 'writing' to mean, 'texting,' or 'typing up an e-mail.' So the term 'writing' didn't exactly fit either."
California looked down at her tennis shoes and sighed. "Ma'am, I can see what you are saying, and one cannot go very far before taking these offenses into account can become awkward. But you have become very sloppy in the way you speak. Perhaps becoming upset over this specific word was the wrong time for me to try and prove my point, but there have been many other times I planned to say something and refrained from speaking, much to my later regret. For instance, the other day you used the word 'police man,' when you could have instead said 'Police officer.' Words like 'manage', 'mania', and 'manners', all of these words mean positive things, and exclude women as a part of it. You really must learn to take these things into account, being a worker of the state in a public school."
"Ahh yes, but you are forgetting words like 'maniac', 'demanding', and 'mandibles'. The first refers to a person of unsavory nature, the second referring to a character trait that no one wishes to be identified with, and the last ones are an unsightly growth on some animals. We are more likely the ones subjecting men to these harms, and yet we do not see them complaining. And do not forget as well, that in changing 'man' to 'woman' you still must incorporate the word 'man.'"
"But we must see fit that women, er, females get the respect they deserve. It is not so much what the word means that is the problem, it is the fact that females are excluded from it. Whether or not people will see it, women are discriminated against!" California said, raising her voice. "Have we ever had a woman president? Of course not! Despite the fact that they've given us the right to vote, and dress according to our wills, they still discriminate according to sexes!"
"Is that really the reason women are not being voted into presidency? African Americans were once considered lower than women, and yet we see today--"
"An African American man."
"--Does the fact that no woman has become president necessarily follow that it is because they are discriminated against? I'm sure with plenty of people like you in the world that is not the problem. Perhaps we have either 1) had unequipped women, excuse me, females," Miss Sophia said with a wink, "running for office, 2) they are, in comparison to other male candidates, a worse choice, 3) they are not Republican or Democratic, and are not being voted on by the majority of our country because the parties containing the most voters is not the one they identify with.
"And are we to find a solution to this problem, if it is indeed a problem, through changing our many vocabulary words containing the term 'man'? I am certain when someone's house is burning down, no one's concern is whether or not they call firemen by their proper, unsexist names. Their only concern is likely to put the fire out.
"You see, people will always be offended, there are people in the world whose purposes are to search for why the world hates them. These people are called 'victims' (they should be happy to see that this word does not exclude any gender.)"
California was upset, very clearly. She was obviously being picked on for her age, she was unequipped to debate someone more than several times her age. People pick on her, and it's because they don't like conflict. They want to remain shut up in their senseless little worlds without reason.
As she silently left, Miss Sophia's husband, Cosmo, entered the room. He noticed California and remained standing, holding the door open with a smile. California inwardly groaned, Typical, she thought, treating me as if I am unequipped to open a door. She stormed out, shaking her head, and with one last glance back, she saw Miss Sophia laughing as Cosmo shrugged his shoulders.
I wouldn't be surprised if many womyn are offended by this insensitive post. What type of persun are you anyway?
ReplyDelete:)
I have to tell the truth
DeleteI am a womyn person:P
Besides, since when has anyone been any fun by being agreeable?:P
Delete